Connect with us

NEWS

Milei’s $LIBRA Case Ends as the Tagged Wallets Empty

An Argentine judge dropped the $LIBRA criminal file against Milei, while tagged Kelsier wallets that once held nearly $300 million now sit under $2 million.

Published

on

Federal Judge Marcelo Martínez de Giorgi on Oct. 23 dropped Argentina’s $LIBRA criminal case against President Javier Milei and 10 others, finding the facts fit no crime.

The same Friday, tagged wallets tied to launch adviser Hayden Davis sat under $2 million, down from nearly $300 million after the February 2025 crash. Milei called the file a coup. Buyers still hold the losses.

A 60-Page Finding That the Crash Was Not Fraud

Martínez de Giorgi, who sits on Federal Criminal and Correctional Court No. 8, accepted a request from prosecutor Eduardo Taiano and closed file CFP 772/2025. The 60-page Oct. 23 court order uses article 336, subsection 3 of the national criminal procedure code, the clause for facts that do not amount to a crime.

He also wrote that opening the file did not stain the good name of the people named in it. None of them had been called in as suspects.

The reported events do not constitute a criminal offence.

Marcelo Martínez de Giorgi, federal judge, Oct. 23 ruling

The coin was minted on Feb. 14, 2025, at 21:38 UTC. Milei posted at 22:01 UTC from his personal X account, calling $LIBRA a private project to fund Argentine small firms and pasting the Solana contract address. By 22:44 UTC the token printed $4.55 and a market cap of $4.5 billion. It then fell more than 90%.

The judge treated that sequence as the memecoin market doing what it does. Estafa under article 172 needs a specific trick, an error that trick caused, and a payment that followed the error. He said a presidential post can give a token extra reach and can feed some buyers’ trust. He also said reach is not a false picture of the project that made people buy.

Losses and a violent chart, he wrote, do not fill that gap on their own. The ruling leaned on an earlier appeals line in the same file: the deeper the probe went, the weaker the first theory of an organized plan to empty pockets through deceit.

CHARGES THE JUDGE DISCARDED

  • Fraud: No concrete false claim was tied to the purchases.
  • Abuse of office: No official act, order or public money was tied to the launch.
  • Incompatible deals: The anti-corruption office treated the post as a personal account, not a presidency channel.
  • Influence peddling: The file did not prove Karina Milei was paid to open doors.

Legal and Technical Secretariat records showed no administrative paper on $LIBRA. On-chain traces, the judge said, also failed to show token proceeds landing with public officials.

Hayden Davis’s Cluster Is Down to $2 Million

Nansen’s February 2025 wallet study is still the cleanest split of who got paid. It is also the part of the story the criminal file never converted into a charge.

THE $LIBRA MONEY SPLIT

Group What the data showed Amount
Traders who lost (86%) Realized losses after the crash $251 million
Traders who won Realized profits $180 million
Davis / pool extraction USDC and SOL pulled from liquidity about $100 million
Kelsier-tagged wallets, Oct. 23 Remaining balance on tagged clusters under $2 million

Davis, the U.S. businessman behind Kelsier Ventures, called himself the launch adviser and said he was sitting on close to $100 million after the dump. He has denied a rug and has said the sum was not his to keep. Arkham later published more than 1,000 Kelsier-tagged addresses, including the Libra cluster that held the pool drain in USDC and SOL.

On Oct. 23, the same day as the Buenos Aires order, that tagged pile was under $2 million. The criminal ruling did not say where the rest went. It said the state had not proved a fraud. Separate on-chain work set out how liquidity left the pools in one-sided Meteora positions rather than a simple market sell.

A dropped case does not put that cash back in the books of the wallets that bought after the president’s post.

Eleven People Cleared Without Suspect Testimony

The order covers Javier Milei; Karina Milei, secretary general of the presidency; Davis; crypto lobbyist Mauricio Novelli of Tech Forum; his partner Manuel Terrones Godoy; former securities-commission adviser Sergio Morales; Julian Peh, chief of KIP Protocol; Novelli’s mother María Alicia Rafaele and sister María Pía Novelli; and Camilo Rodríguez Blanco and Orlando Mellino.

That is 11 names, and the judge said the lack of suspect interviews was not a bar to ending the case. People named in a probe, he wrote, have a right to a final answer on their status.

Karina Milei’s paper trail, as the order read it, shrank to one documented act: she authorized Davis’s entry to the Casa Rosada on July 16, 2024. Taken alone, the judge wrote, that pass does not prove an illicit deal. He also declined to treat unsigned notes on Novelli’s phone, including a draft that pointed to a person labelled “H,” as a paid-access scheme.

Milei deleted the original post hours later, after midnight on Feb. 15 in Buenos Aires, and wrote that he had not known the details and had no link to the venture. In the days after the crash he said he had acted in good faith. He compared unhappy buyers to people who complain after they lose at a casino.

The political cost of that post was always going to be larger than the legal theory. A sitting president pasted a brand-new contract address into a feed that trades on his name. The court answered a narrower question: whether that post, the spike and the dump were a crime in the code. It said no.

Buyers Lost Their Place in the Case in July

The order can still be appealed, but the people who say they were harmed are not currently inside the file. That is the procedural fact the victory lap skips.

HOW THE BUYERS LEFT THE FILE

  1. July 3, 2026: The judge removes five investors as private complainants after a request from Novelli’s defense.
  2. Sept. 4, 2026: Appeals judges Mariano Llorens and Pablo Bertuzzi uphold the removal, writing that buyers took on the risk of a volatile, unregulated bet.
  3. Sept. 16, 2026: The excluded buyers ask the Federal Criminal Cassation Court to put them back in.
  4. Oct. 23, 2026: With only the prosecutor left to carry the case, Taiano asks for dismissal and the judge grants it.

The five were Alan Vega, Braian Emanuel Quintero, Matías Alejandro Paris, Juan Patricio Marchetto and Martín Romeo. The appeals panel said none of them had shown a specific false statement that caused their purchases. Deputies Mónica Frade and Maximiliano Ferraro, who filed the first complaint, were also kept out as complainants.

Once those private parties were gone, the file lived or died on Taiano. He asked the judge to end it. National deputy Juan Grabois, who had backed the private complaints, said the prosecutor had behaved like a defense lawyer. The insults in his replies did not add facts. The sequence in the docket does.

The court file itself put the buyer count above 40,000. Nansen’s 86% losing share was a trader study, not a census of every wallet, and it still left a pile of realized losses with no defendant ordered to pay them.

New York Had Already Closed the Other Door

U.S. District Judge Jennifer L. Rochon of the Southern District of New York dismissed the investor class action against Kelsier Labs, Davis, Meteora and former Meteora chief Benjamin Chow on Sept. 29, with prejudice, and told the clerk to close the case.

Rochon held that six months of memecoin launches did not plead a RICO pattern. Claims against Meteora failed because the plaintiffs had not shown it was an association or partnership that can be sued. Remaining state-law claims against the Davis side fell for lack of New York jurisdiction. The court did not try those claims on the merits.

So by the time Buenos Aires archived its criminal file, the main U.S. civil vehicle was already dead. Buyers who wanted a court to chase the pool drain now have a cassation complaint in Argentina and a closed docket in Manhattan.

Milei Frames the Archive as a Coup

The presidential office treated the dismissal as absolute proof of innocence and asked who would pay for wasting public money and the president’s time on a failed institutional coup. Milei put a clock on it: one year, eight months and nine days of lies, slander and insults, the span from the Feb. 14 post to the Oct. 23 order.

At a Fundación Faro dinner the same night, he said opponents had tried a coup by institutional means and failed, and he went after reporters who covered the coin. The legal holding is thinner than that speech. The judge did not try Milei and acquit him. He found the facts in the file were not a crime and that nobody had been heard as a suspect.

WHERE THE ARGUMENTS SPLIT

  • The presidency: The inquiry was free, the result is innocence, and the complaint was a coup attempt.
  • Juan Grabois: The dismissal is impunity, built by removing the complainants and letting the prosecutor ask for the archive.
  • The order itself: No criminally relevant deception was proved, and a price crash is not fraud without that proof.

Those three sentences can all be true in their own lane. A president can be free of a criminal charge and still have lit a chart with a contract address. A deputy can call that outcome impunity without turning the code’s fraud test into something it is not. The judge can be right on article 172 and still leave the money trail unanswered.

What the $LIBRA Investigation Never Finished

Chequeado’s reading of the order, and the order’s own caveats, list the holes that never got filled. They are why a no-crime stamp feels larger than the evidence the state actually closed.

GAPS LEFT IN THE FILE

  • The calls: Forensics found calls between Milei and Novelli on launch day and could not recover what was said.
  • Deleted chats: Two erased threads sat under a contact labelled “Karina Milei RRPP.”
  • The money map: Cybercrime units traced issuance wallets, then hit missing licences, partial exchange replies and a U.S. assistance file that American authorities shut for weak grounds.
  • The boxes: Novelli’s safe-deposit boxes showed traffic near the launch and were empty when raided.
  • The phones: A DATIP employee reached reserved material that later hit the press. The judge said weak control hurt the chain of custody and the weight of that digital proof.

International help that never arrived matters for a token launched by a U.S. adviser on Solana. If the pool drain lived on foreign platforms, a Buenos Aires file that cannot compel those records will always look like a chart without the last column.

The dismissal is not yet final. Excluded buyers still have a cassation complaint aimed at getting back into the case so they can challenge the archive. Until that door opens, the 11 names walk, the tagged cluster shows under $2 million, and $LIBRA remains a coin a president posted, a judge declined to call a crime, and a market already finished with.

Disclaimer: This article is news reporting and analysis of a criminal case and related court filings. It is informational only and is not legal, investment, tax or trading advice. It does not tell readers to buy, sell or hold $LIBRA or any other token, and it does not tell readers how to bring or drop a claim. Consult a qualified lawyer in the relevant country, and a licensed financial adviser, before acting on any court outcome or token. Figures, wallet tags and case status reflect the cited orders, research notes and on-chain tags as used in this reporting and can change if an appeal lands or if tagged balances move.

Harry is the editor of CRYPTO QUILL. He owns the site and runs it independently, covering bitcoin, altcoins, exchanges, DeFi, NFTs and the regulation of blockchain markets. His ten years in journalism began as a reporter and ended up in the editor's chair, with most of that decade spent on digital asset markets. He works from primary material rather than press releases: on-chain records pulled from block explorers, exchange order book and volume data, proof of reserves attestations, token unlock schedules, court dockets, and the enforcement actions and consultations published by financial regulators. Market figures are checked against at least two independent data sources before they appear, and if a number later proves wrong the article is corrected in place under the site's public corrections policy. Harry does not give investment advice; crypto rules differ by jurisdiction and prices can go to zero, so readers should treat every story as information, not a recommendation. Reader mail is answered at support@cryptoquill.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending